Shhh… The 3 secrets of commuting by bike

Tweed cyclist smoking pipeOh. My. God. How do people cycle to work each day, like this, are they mental? This was my reaction to commuting in London recently despite the fact I’ve commuted in the city by bike for over ten years.

So what changed? Well I moved house and had to find a new route to work. Lazy, I began with a direct route on major roads. Never, ever, ever again. No room to manoeuvre, to enjoy, to breathe. Cars, buses, motorbikes, cyclists. Everywhere. Swarms of the things. Overwhelmed, my brain fried and nerves frayed.

I began riding like a newbie. I slowed and prayed for stabilizers. My usual positive position on the road away from the kerb was merely an invite for dozens of cyclists to undertake me. Uncertain of my route and unsure of myself, I became hesitant, traffic of all varieties surging and merging all around me. Scary.

Cars were the last of my worries. Buses pulling out, cyclists weaving, sorry, filtering, motorbikes aggressively accelerating. Did I mention the traffic lights? Billions of them. I spent more time waiting than riding.

To add to my new-found inexperience I was riding my weekend bike, the brakes on the hoods giving me a lower, more aero position, very much unsuited to keeping an eye on the madness all around me.

I got home stressed, questioning my sanity. My shoulders tight, I was mentally exhausted. If this had been my first cycle commute I would have sold the bike and never complained about the tube again. Who in their right mind would want to commute in such chaos?

The next day? I took the time to craft a route through London’s many back roads. Bliss. I was back in love with cycling again, amazed why anyone would want to cycle on the mean streets. Cycle commuting in London is actually pleasant once you avoid the main roads and find one of the many quiet routes.

Commuting secrets

Cyclist on the frozen River Thames, preferable to the roads

Secret 1 // Do not cycle on busy routes

Find a quiet way, a B road, a Z road, a dedicated cycle route, a bus lane or shortcuts through housing estates or parks. Do not use the A routes or main thoroughfares, even if that’s the route you know. As a commuter you’ll hit rush hour and rush hour may just hit back.

Secret 2 // Do not cycle on busy routes

Seriously.

Secret 3 // No more secrets

That’s right, that’s all you need to make commuting enjoyable. Sure you can worry about the right clothes, suitable bikes, being visible, tyre widths and the like, but nothing will keep you safer or make your ride more enjoyable than keeping away from the busy roads and junctions.

So tell your friends, help new cyclists find quiet routes to work and don’t be lazy like I was. Plan or stumble upon those lovely secret back routes. You’ll discover more of your city, find new roads and hidden short-cuts, new views and most importantly, the space and time to enjoy your ride. Just be sure to keep off the pavement unless you’re happy to dismount.

Best cycle mapping tools

Cycling Regent's ParkI love planning bike routes. Crafting the perfect route, away from traffic, quiet roads but not too small they are poorly maintained, routes with hills, with food stops, with views. Each new line is a new road to discover and I genuinely get very excited about riding the lines I’m plotting. My saved routes are like art to me, an archive of pleasure, of memories or roads I’m still to ride.

Cycle navigation has come on leaps and bounds in the past few years yet there’s still not a perfect mapping tool for this cyclist. I want a mapping service that will 1) find me quiet roads, 2) will not take me down dirt tracks, 3) will avoid pavements, 4) will give me Streetview so I can see dodgy junctions and 5) will easily export to my phone/GPS device. To my knowledge this isn’t possible in one application, particularly points 1-3.

  • Cycle.Travel was recommended in the comments of this blog by its creator, Richard. I love it. It’s similar to Cycle Streets below in that it’s main objective is to route you down the quietest routes, perfect for cycling in London. The clever bit is that it uses actual traffic numbers to determine which roads you should use.

    The routes it offered me were new routes, something I rarely get as an experienced cyclist in London. And you know what? They are great routes. Quiet, yet still direct. It does route you down some footpaths but they are visibly marked with an icon and you can simply drag and drop the route to avoid the walking sections. You can also export the route when you’re done and see all of the junctions before you ride them. I’d recommend using Cycle.Travel to plot your routes and then using your Garmin to follow the route. I found it difficult to follow a route on my phone. RideWithGPS has a premium feature that may work. Strava has a lab (beta) feature that may work in future – currently broken. MapMyRide’s app routing is pretty poor and crashed the first time I took it for a spin.
  • Cycle Streets is also a great place to start planning your route. It gives you three options, a choice of quiet roads, speed or a balance. The site even tells you the pollution levels and the number of traffic lights on your route. Brilliant! Be careful though, the recommended routes also include walking and pavement, which is a major drawback if you like to remain on your bike as I do. You can’t edit routes like you can with Cycle.Travel which means avoiding dead ends when you encounter footpaths is not great. Still, it’s a great place to start finding quiet routes to work.

    Tip: The base map it uses is horrible but can be changed by using the little ‘layer’ symbol in the top right of the map. Once you have created a route there’s even more base map options, including Google Maps.
  • Strava routes comes close to being the perfect mapping tool depending on where you live. The ‘most popular routes’ feature is fantastic at showing you the most cycled country lanes but in the city tends to plonk you on the main roads, the very ones you want to avoid. Strava also doesn’t separate mountain bikes routes from road routes, a pretty fundamental requirement (odd given they have this data)! Plus they have removed Google Streetview. I like to see my enemies (i.e. busy roads and junctions).
  • Google Maps was once one of the best tools for me. The specific routing for cyclists is pretty patchy (dirt tracks, pavement, etc) but I used to get by adapting car routes aiming for smaller roads and using Streetview to ensure all roads are safe. Few sites used to have the ability to drag and plot routes like Google, but this has changed recently. Plus the latest Google Map updates make it difficult for you to export routes to a cycle specific GPX device like a Garmin.

    Tip: I hate riding a route which sends my precious clean bike down a dirt or gravel track. You can avoid this by creating your route and then dragging the yellow Streetview man above the map without actually placing it on the map. Google will then highlight all roads in blue that have Streetview, giving you an excellent indication of where the Streetview car has been, which is 99% certain to be well surfaced roads. You can quickly see any part of your route which doesn’t have Streetview and know this is likely (not always) to be a mud track or road that needs closer inspection.
  • RidewithGPS was my mapping tool of choice until I wrote this blog and got reader recommendations. Streetview is present so you can see your routes. You can drag and change the route easily and exporting is also good. The interface isn’t the most user-friendly and a little ugly in places but it does the basic job well. The app is good, although you need to go premium to follow imported routes.

What about you, what’s your favourite cycle mapping tool? Any new sites out there? I must admit I’ve not strayed beyond the same sites I’ve been using for years.

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Advertisements

18 thoughts on “Shhh… The 3 secrets of commuting by bike

  1. I use an iOS app called ‘Footpath’ which I love, but we’re more rural. I’ll use it initially and then go back to mapmyride. It probably doesn’t have many of the tools you’d want, but it’s such a joy to use.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I looked at that before, looks very well designed. I’m on Android so will have to wait! Something like that for cycling would be great, no reason why you shouldn’t be able to create routes directly on your phone, that would be ideal.

      Like

    • London’s like that. It does weird stuff to us all! That said I was amazed by the number of dedicated cycle routes I rode along today, pretty amazing, even going against the tide of one way systems.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Ride with GPS for creating maps, but truth be told, when I’m on the road, it’s always easiest to pull up Google Maps, and if the route looks good, follow that. Some areas in the US have the option for cycling routes. Not always. Ah our never ending search for the perfect cycling navigation.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I like the idea of navigating on the fly, which is what I do on walking trips. I think I’m less inclined to stop cycling. Our search continues indeed, although I still remember trying to navigate with paper maps. In the rain. Never again!

      Like

  3. Another great article and since I recently had an accident it got me thinking. Another great app to use is Bike Hub. You can choose different route dependant on speed, distance or quietness of route.

    Like

    • Thanks Gary – accidents can happen anywhere but you can certainly reduce the odds by reducing the number of cars you encounter! Just had a quick look at Bike Hub – it’s using the same routing as CycleStreets, love the ‘CO2 avoided’ feature. Just realised this comes in app format too so will give this a go.

      Like

  4. Favourite tool is http://cycle.travel/map – but I’m biased because I made it!

    But it’s particularly relevant to your first two points because it uses real traffic numbers for A roads, i.e. the number of motor vehicles on a road. So it won’t route you on a central London A road unless it really has to, but it won’t worry about (say) a crazily quiet A road in the Scottish Highlands. Plus draggable routes like Google, and Geograph pics so you can see what the route will be like (even on bridleways and cycle paths). Always very happy to hear feedback!

    Liked by 1 person

    • That looks interesting, thanks Richard, a really good way to try to solve the problem. I just tried on my mobile and got a route I’d not considered before – always a good sign! There was a bit of footpath involved – I shall take a closer look the next time I’m on a desktop (for mobile, it’d be great to have a ‘use my current location’ feature).

      Like

    • Hi Richard, have been spending some time with your site. I’m really enjoying using it and seeing the different routes it is throwing at me – will take them for a spin this week and see how I get on. Will also add you to the blog above as I think your routing is better than the others I’ve added. Initial feedback:

      – Saving a route – would be good to give me an option to log-in/create an account once I have created a route
      – Ability to follow a route. Your routes in an app I could use to follow the routes would be amazing. As it is I need to export and without my garmin to hand I’m struggling to get this route onto my phone without downloading another app.
      – Love the round trip feature and the ability to change the route
      – Great that you pull out walking sections so I can change my route to avoid them (like the cobbled feature too for rough roads).

      Great job

      Like

  5. Perversely A roads in London can be the safest and quickest route where you are happy to keep up with he traffic (~20mph), especially where there are widened bus lanes that can be used. Commercial Road in East London feels safe than mixing it with the hoardes on CS3 along dangerous narrow cable street

    Liked by 1 person

    • That’s a good point, often look for stretches with bus lanes myself but even they can be hectic in places, especially at traffic lights when the bus lane disappears. It’s all about experimenting. I’m still refining my route!

      Like

  6. Pingback: What I’ve Been Reading | Eat And Run This

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s